Now, for all I know, it might be true that the Queen really is an "uneducated" philistine, but if I were the one going to make such an accusation, I'd at least try to get my quotes right. When David Starkey says
"I think she's got elements a bit like Goebbels in her attitude to culture," the historian told the Guardian. "You remember: 'Every time I hear the word culture I reach for my revolver.' "
He displays the shallowness of his own historical knowledge: the original source of this notorious "quote" wasn't Goebbels or Goering or any other Nazi bigwig who said such a thing, but a character in a 1933 play called "Schlageter", which was written by a fellow called Hanns Johst. Worse yet, what the character actually said was
"Wenn ich Kultur höre ... entsichere ich meinen Browning"
In other words, while we can't be certain of the Queen of England's philistinism - and given the attitudes of the British aristocracy towards learning, it's quite possible that she
is a philistine - one thing we
can be certain of is that David Starkey is your typical pretentious tw*t who thinks he can pass himself off as an "intellectual" by regurgitating bits and pieces of pseudo-knowledge. That he thinks Prince Charles (of all people!) to be the "best hope" for the monarchy just happens to reveal how little judgment Mr. Starkey has.
PS: Oh, and by the way, it is a serious historical error to assume that Joseph Goebbels was some sort of aesthetic ignoramus just because of the vile things the man said and did for public consumption. Of all the Nazi leadership, Goebbels seems to have been by far the most cynical about what he said to the masses and what he truly believed, and the Propaganda Minister's own tastes actually ran to the "degenerate" art and architecture he condemned on his master's behalf rather than to the tired neoclassicism worshiped by Hitler. Goebbels was not a philistine, nor was Reinhard Heydrich or many other a butcher of the Third Reich - yet another black mark against David Starkey.
Recent Comments